Ratings are generally 3-5 stars, which is my bottle-worthy range. No stars means it's a blind buy that's not yet tested, or it is horrifying. For some scents, I have included my wife's opinion in my evaluation.
(*****) One of my favorites, or an old favorite that's so classic it gets to keep the stars
(****) Excellent - I love it.
(***) Nice, but not one that I reach for very often when not testing.
(**) Bothers me slightly. Possibly changed my mind about it, or bought blind. Unlikely to be in my collection.
(*) I really don't like it.
() Not yet tested ... or... OMG - this is a fragrance?