Yatagan - Vintage or go with anything?

Nattyboh74

Well-known member
Oct 24, 2018
I looked and some.older threads say to get whatever as it's damn close. But lately from what Ive seen reviews wise, the performance is terrible on new new stuff. Should I go deep sword vintage or maybe early 2000 batch?
 

Varanis Ridari

The Scented Devil
Basenotes Plus
Oct 17, 2012
Castoreum musk is a bit funkier in vintage, but still present in current. Recent leans more towards the chewy herbs which some call "celery", although oregano a big part of the cause. Vintage sees that facet dialed down some to be more blended with the rest. I do like both versions I've picked up (modern white label and old red), but ever-so-slightly lean towards older.
 

GoldWineMemories

Well-known member
Nov 22, 2019
As a smell I enjoy Yatagan I've worn it all summer and gone through a 100ml bottle. It's wonderful stuff all I can say though is that it has little projection, and doesn't last long on my skin. I have no idea if the vintage will serve that purpose better, but this is not a bombastic perfume.
 

Tristan45

Well-known member
Jun 30, 2017
Current is marvellous, but a good well-kept vintage is laden with real castoreum and gives it a warmth and animalic hum slightly lacking in the current version. As others have said the celery note is not as prominent (but that could just be a function of the age of the juice, it's difficult to tell). The only way to get Caron to keep making it though is to buy the current one.
 

Latest News

Top