Which long lasting Daily…

[pouring]

Purchase Tyger yesterday. Love the opening but I can’t detect it after 20 mins on me.

Either new bottle needs to macerate it my nose has gone blind to the ambroxan.

However - not sure it’s better than other long lasting scents I have.

What is the forums favourite every day west out of

• Tyger
• Antico Caruso
• Invasion Barbare
• Percival
• Tobacco Vanille
• Sauvage Elixir
• Haltane
• Aventus Cologne
• Relfection Man
• Aqua allegoria forte nerolia vetiver

Choice is making me anxious and want to pick and stay with one for a month.

(Other alternatives include Paris Edimbourg which are not as long lasting)

Thanks

 

[StylinLA]

I'm most partial to Invasion Barbare and to a lesser degree Reflection Man.

As to long lasting.... I lose track of Invasion Barbare after about 4-5 hours, but I have had people comment on it much longer than that.

Reflection Man seemed to stay more present to my nose much longer but I prefer IB and can live with the scent blindness.

 

[dogtoe]

I just wore Invasion Barbare today. It’s very much my style. I spray my shirt and it lasts a good 6 hours. It’s not too aggressive.

Elixir can be too aggressive if over sprayed. It, too, lasts a good long time. However, the scent is completely different from IB.

I also enjoy Reflection which is about as reserved as IB, perhaps a bit stronger. It, too, lasts a good long time. I consider both Reflection and IB to be good office scents.

I don’t own any of the others you listed.

 

[Melbourne21]

Percival for me

 

[TR10]

another vote for MDCI Invasion Barbare

 

[Marty McFly]

Tygar is one of my favorite fragrances, and certainly my top choice of those you posted. I find it has very strong performance, and I suspect you are going nose-blind. You could try Sospiro Vibrato which smells extremely similar to Tygar and has super longevity and projection.

Percival, which you mentioned, also performs quite well and I really enjoy it, although it is less original and very invocative of AF Fierce or MB Legend.

 

[hednic]

Invasion Barbare

 

[Toxicon]

Maybe try varying where you spray? I still run into this from time to time with certain scents (often ISO E heavy scents like Fahrenheit), where I randomly get crappy performance but will catch a whiff 12 hours later and realize it's my nose, not the scent. Some scents do this to me no matter what, like Guerlain Homme L'eau Boisee; other times I can spray further down my chest and get much better longevity. Anyway, best of luck!

The only one from your list I've tried is Paris-Edimbourg. Gorgeous scent, but it is a light performer; low projection, decent longevity, but it's pretty quiet the whole time.

 

[AndyL]

Purchase Tyger yesterday. Love the opening but I can’t detect it after 20 mins on me.

Not exclusively, but many of my bottles get better with use and time. It's not uncommon for a new fragrance, even new vintage fragrances, to appear dull and lackluster at first. But with use and time, for whatever reason, they come around.

 

[PrinceRF]

From your list, despite there being a few I have not yet tried, my favorite would be Tobacco Vanille.

 

[pouring]

Thanks All….

 

[Ken_Russell]

Would most likely recommend and also likely go for: a tie/high (est) ranking between either of the following options: TF Tobacco Vanille, Sauvage Elixir and/or the Aqua Allegoria choice.

 

[lfc1892]

Reflection

 

[freewheelingvagabond]

Either Invasion Barbare or Antico Caruso.