Vintage SOTD Thread for May 2023

[Diddy]

Hey Diddy! Yes, I made that mistake last summer, and Arden Sandalwood is now a top 5 for me... The bone dry, aromatic structure is right up my alley, and it performs extremely well in any weather due to a 'sharpness'. Gucci Nobile is the only other aromatic that comes close in the heat, as it is pretty dry as well.



Dead gummit, now I've got to try some vintage Eternity... Thanks for the heads-up on this one!

Regarding Eternity FOR MEN/for men:

1. Do NOT search "vintage" as that will only lead to sellers charging higher prices for the buzzword.
2. Only purchase from sellers posting a photo of the actual bottle, including labeling.
3. Look for - Eternity FOR MEN (CK distribution) or Eternity for men (Unilever distribution). Silver/chrome stickers on the bottom of the bottle will tell you the distributor. I've not tried Lancaster distribution, but would not be afraid to give it a whirl. The original release has "FOR MEN" all caps but be aware that CK went back to the all caps for modern bottles, therefore making the distributor the key to successfully acquiring vintage.
4. This basic history of logo is: Eternity FOR MEN (CK distribution), Eternity for men (CK distribution), Eternity for men (Unilever distribution), Eternity for men (Lancaster distribution, very briefly).... Don't waste dollars on any other formulation as they only mimic the top notes of the vintage and miss out on the true development of the fragrance.
5. I recently purchased a 100ml spray bottle of 'for men' CK distribution for $24 plus free shipping. A quick ebay search will reveal that there is an abundance (at least in the USA) of vintage stuff for $30 or less.

Unfortunately, sellers may very well use this information I've just posted to try to get more money. So it's also important for me to say this... I'm not suggesting that Eternity FOR MEN is a holy grail or greatest ever etc etc etc fragrance. NO. It is a fragrance that has an important place in history. @Varanis Ridari has a great write up on it here https://basenotes.com/review/239708 . It is a fragrance that is SUPER easy to wear. It's pleasant and won't offend anyone, unless they were held hostage and tortured by someone who wore it. It's a blind reach. All of that is part of why it was such a huge hit when it was released, and why it still continues to be produced and sold today. IF someone is interested in this fragrance, then I can only recommend getting it in vintage form as the modern version of it just doesn't do enough for me. As stated before, the vintage version has an all important sandalwood note that is very light but serves as an important anchor for the overall presentation. In vintage form, the top notes also die back and the fragrance takes on a somewhat different presentation. At that point you will understand where some other fragrances took inspiration. The modern version is all about the top notes. As pleasant as those may be, the modern version is a solid 'meh' for me.

 

[Redfish365]

Monsieur Rochas EDC & EDT (1969)
(Wearing the EDC under the EDT. Just a blissful fragrance, old-school and beautiful.)

 

[N.CAL Fragrance Reviewer]

Guerlain Mitsouko PDT and perfume Extrait concentrations. It turns out they work nicely together, going hand in hand complementing each other.

 

[speedyrabbit]

Congrats!

Thanks bud, what a surprise with that kouros

 

[Ken_Russell]

Halston 1-12

 

[JoM68]

SOTD 1980s YSL Paris - Charles of the Ritz mini.

 

[hednic]

SOTE: Ignis by Omar Sharif

 

[Varanis Ridari]

Basile Uomo Forte (1989)

Seemed a good choice to keep in theme this week.

 

[N.CAL Fragrance Reviewer]

Guerlain Sous Le Vent. I'm wearing the original 1930s formulation with the 2000s re-release.

 

[Diddy]

Guerlain Sous Le Vent. I'm wearing the original 1930s formulation with the 2000s re-release.

View attachment 336055

That second bottle seems futurism art from a 60’s perspective to me. I really like it!

 

[purecaramel]

I'll be wearing La Nuit by Paco Rabanne in honour of Tina Turner.
Not necessarily something she would have worn.
However, my First wearing had the very same effect upon me, as first witnessing Tina's explosion of Raw Feminine Energy on the stage of "The Cave" mid 70's.
The mix of Deep Contralto voice and, indeed, toned, taut Amazon Thighs had my Teenage Heart in Swoon for the whole event and into the week.

 

[speedyrabbit]

BOOM

 

[Jean-Sté]

Brut, Fabergé. 1964. Karl Mann.

Layering after-shave with eau de toilette. This version is concentrated, no need to overspray.

 

[Martialisaragon]

Trophée (1982) by Lancôme
Mostly a citrus chypre. To say that it is a (20th century) classicist scent wouldn't be entirely out of place, I believe.

 

[Puma]

Mitsouko

 

[perfaddict]

Bijan for Men spray cologne

 

[Jean-Sté]

Mitsouko
View attachment 336086

What a nice collection ! Congratulations !

 

[Pheusinger]

Caron - Pour Un Homme cologne

Caron Pour Un Homme perfume information, consumer reviews, where to buy, perfume notes and more... Pour Un Homme is a men's fragrance launched in 1934 by Caron

basenotes.com

Guerlain - Jicky Eau de Parfum perfume

Guerlain Jicky Eau de Parfum perfume information, consumer reviews, where to buy, perfume notes and more... Jicky Eau de Parfum is a shared scent launched in 1889 by Guerlain

basenotes.com

 

[WarmJewel]

Paloma Picasso - Minotaure, Aftershave.

First full wearing of this one. From the reviews I read I had a feeling I would like this and I wasn't wrong. Very ambery and reminds me a lot of Nicole Miller for Men and Escada Pour Homme. Perfect for warmer weather.

e2a It suddenly occurred to me that given this is distributed by Cosmair, the batch code would be the same as the Armani codes. So, ULXX would be 1992, so launch year!

 

[WarmJewel]

Guerlain Sous Le Vent. I'm wearing the original 1930s formulation with the 2000s re-release.

I recently saw an unopened boxed example of the second picture version on that popular auction site, last time I looked it as up to £1,500...

 

[WarmJewel]

Trophée (1982) by Lancôme
Mostly a citrus chypre. To say that it is a (20th century) classicist scent wouldn't be entirely out of place, I believe.

I recently tried a small miniature of this and it's the first Lancome fragrance I've tried I really didn't like! Not for me!

 

[JON RODGERS]

Creed Aubepine-Acacia.

 

[Redfish365]

I recently tried a small miniature of this and it's the first Lancome fragrance I've tried I really didn't like! Not for me!

I've been considering adding it to my collection as a blind buy.
Can you briefly describe what it is you dislike about it? Was it a newer or older bottle? I'm on the fence...

 

[Martialisaragon]

Not for me!

What was it you disliked, compared with others of its ilk?

 

[Professor Value]

I've been considering adding it to my collection as a blind buy.
Can you briefly describe what it is you dislike about it? Was it a newer or older bottle? I'm on the fence...

I've got a mini bottle and suggest going that way first; nice but no wow. Kind of a dry, earthy green scent. Reminds me a little of R de Capucci. Not bad; I'd probably like it more if I didn't already have others in that neighborhood. I really don't reach for it.

 

[Professor Value]

Spraying from my 200 ml jumbo bottle this morning before going out for a run. #SOTM 🖤 💛 🏃

AZZARO POUR HOMME

 

[WarmJewel]

What was it you disliked, compared with others of its ilk?

You made me dig it out and try it again and now I want to wash if off!

I think it's the basil doing it or a combination of basil, lime and Jasmine, I'm not sure. There are certain note/accords that I simply don't like, Cumin is another I struggle with and is the main reason I don't like Cartier Declaration.

There's always a chance of course it's starting to turn or has turned but the other miniature fragrances in the set I bought seem fine so I don't think it's that. It might also be that because it's fairly citrus orientated, it's lost a lot of its top citrus notes, which can often produce a bit of an odd fragrance.

Whatever it is, it doesn't sit happily with me!

 

[WarmJewel]

I've been considering adding it to my collection as a blind buy.
Can you briefly describe what it is you dislike about it? Was it a newer or older bottle? I'm on the fence...

It was from a miniature set from the early 90's so not a new one. For what I didn't like about it, see above!

 

[Redfish365]

It was from a miniature set from the early 90's so not a new one. For what I didn't like about it, see above!

Wonderful! Thank you for pointing me in the right direction. Sometimes I bump into walls!! Excellent rationale there though, much appreciated!

 

[Jean-Sté]

Not bad; I'd probably like it more if I didn't already have others in that neighborhood. I really don't reach for it.

I agree.

 

[cologne connoisseur]

Moustache EDT Concentree

 

[Redfish365]

Eau Cendrée by Jacomo (1974)
(My favorite Jacomo, a house that has made a few gems.)

 

[purecaramel]

Brut, Fabergé. 1964. Karl Mann.

Layering after-shave with eau de toilette. This version is concentrated, no need to overspray.

View attachment 336068

I Love the whole thing of layering.
As to the Brut. Distinctive scent surely.
My initial tasting in the 70's was way too Brutish for my tastes at the time.
I suppose I need to try it on again after all these years

 

[Jean-Sté]

I Love the whole thing of layering.
As to the Brut. Distinctive scent surely.
My initial tasting in the 70's was way too Brutish for my tastes at the time.
I suppose I need to try it on again after all these years

Indeed, I think our tastes change while we grow. Be sure to look for a vintage Brut.

 

[N.CAL Fragrance Reviewer]

Chanel Egoiste EDT and Egoiste Cologne Concentree is something I decided to give a go. While the EDT adds a bit more sweetness and vanilla, the Cologne concentred adds more spice and sandalwood. Not a bad combination I must say.

 

[CookBot]

Honoring the birthday of the late and much-lamented Quarry with one of her top-ten favorites.

Bel Ami (1986) by Jean-Lous Sieuzac for Hermès

 

[purecaramel]

Honoring the birthday of the late and much-lamented Quarry with one of her top-ten favorites.

Bel Ami (1986) by Jean-Lous Sieuzac for Hermès

View attachment 336140

I think I will join you this Evening.
Less than hour ago I was rolling through some of her past posts and thinking of her joyous Spirit.

 

[CookBot]

Mitsouko

Ooo, soap and powder too. Envious.

As to the Brut. Distinctive scent surely.
My initial tasting in the 70's was way too Brutish for my tastes at the time.
I suppose I need to try it on again after all these years

Same here. I recall Brut as harsh and mean, and I've been surprised by its renaissance here on Basenotes. Maybe I too should give it another try sometime.

 

[purecaramel]

Ooo, soap and powder too. Envious.



Same here. I recall Brut as harsh and mean, and I've been surprised by its renaissance here on Basenotes. Maybe I too should give it another try sometime.

Yes,
Puma's Mitsouko Treasure Chest has me envious as well!

 

[purecaramel]

Mitsouko
View attachment 336086

Yum!