I used to own a bottle of Vaniglia del Madagascar, it's a good lemon infused vanilla scent. Indult Tihota is the best straight forward vanilla scent that I've smelled personally.
You should both give Shalimar Ode a la vanille flankers a sniff.
Versace - Eros Parfum 100ml
Blind buy, let's see how it goes. Hopefully better than the EdP.
I did like it! I may like the original EdT from my 2011/2012 or so bottle, and the Eros Flame flanker the best. I seem to go quite noseblind to the range (not sure on EdT though).I haven't tried the edp..You didn't like it?
I have the edt from '15 and it's quite good.
However the very first batches from '13 had monstrous performance. They have toned it down since then probably to make room for these more intense flankers.