midnight in paris

[lovetribe]

Midnight in paris Van Cleef & Arpels



VS



Midnight in Paris Eau de Parfum Van Cleef & Arpels





which is better and why?



thanks.

 

[hednic]

I own both but I prefer the EDP as it lasts longer and performs better for me.

 

[lovetribe]

i too

 

[sunny5011]

EDP! the best

 

[Foamywax]

Wish I had bought a bottle of midnight in paris before they axed it. I don't see it anywhere anymore.

 

[sjg3839]

Can't go wrong on either one.

 

[RedRaider430]

I preferred the EdT of this. It simply smelled the best to me.

 

[FragFrog]

I prefer Prada Luna Rossa Black over both Midnight in Paris versions.

 

[bibo]

full wearing of this scent today..EDP, wifey asked me what I was wearing and that is really a plus, she knows of my neverending wardrobe and when she asks me what I got on, I know is something she particularly likes...

 

[lovetribe]

grazie

 

[Franco65]

had it on yesterday's night, had forgotten this gem how good it is!

 

[ascotnot]

Boy, that's gone up a lot in price since I last saw my bottle of it. I'll have to make an extra effort to find it this year. I don't even remember whether mine is an EDP.

 

[hednic]

Boy, that's gone up a lot in price since I last saw my bottle of it. .

What's it going for now. The EDP retailed for $110 when it launched, and the EDT for $90

 

[Diddy]

What's it going for now. The EDP retailed for $110 when it launched, and the EDT for $90

4.2oz listed for $399 on the Bay right now. I gave my bottle away but nearly kept it just because I thought the bottle was so nice. Lol. My brother @Mythrol still has a bottle, I think. I thought the fragrance was well done but not much wow factor for me. A style thing I suppose. FWIW my wife crinkled her nose, in a bad way, every time I let her smell it.

 

[tspencer]

Wow. I just looked at Ebay. Ridiculous. Holy crap I just looked in my closet stash and I have 3 75ml backup bottles of the EDT. I forgot I had that many. I thought I only had backup 1 bottle. Not selling them. they're mine.

 

[ripjean]

Yep prices for this are mad now. I bought 3 x 75ml edp version for around £16 each years ago. I opened one and have barely made a dent in it. I need to revisit it ASAP!

 

[Franco65]

Boy, that's gone up a lot in price since I last saw my bottle of it. I'll have to make an extra effort to find it this year. I don't even remember whether mine is an EDP.

4.2oz listed for $399 on the Bay right now. I gave my bottle away but nearly kept it just because I thought the bottle was so nice. Lol. My brother @Mythrol still has a bottle, I think. I thought the fragrance was well done but not much wow factor for me. A style thing I suppose. FWIW my wife crinkled her nose, in a bad way, every time I let her smell it.

Wow. I just looked at Ebay. Ridiculous. Holy crap I just looked in my closet stash and I have 3 75ml backup bottles of the EDT. I forgot I had that many. I thought I only had backup 1 bottle. Not selling them. they're mine.

Yep prices for this are mad now. I bought 3 x 75ml edp version for around £16 each years ago. I opened one and have barely made a dent in it. I need to revisit it ASAP!

Let's face the truth.. this little gem is far superior than a lot of so called "niche" cr#p! Glad I backed it up, back in the day!

 

[wampa]

I remember seeing the EDP on sale online for $25 back in the day. It's a nice powdery scent scent and prefer the EDP over the EDT. The EDT is a little sharp in the opening unlike the EDP which is much smoother.

 

[Bonnette]

I prefer the EDT, for precisely the reason that others opt for the EDP. The EDT is a tad sharper, more in-focus than the EDP...when a perfume is already powdery, I sometimes like the slight edge of an EDT, as the notes stand out in slightly more relief.

 

[_Nicolas_]

The EDP was always too powdery and smelled less 'nuanced' to me somehow, it just didn't seem to have the same subtlety in its development. Glad I have 20ml of the EDT left. Doesn't seem like much, but it's such a rare wear it's a lifetime's supply for me!

 

[thrilledchilled]

I love this fragrance. Both the EDP and EDT, probably leaning to the EDP for similar reason as Hednic, performance.

 

[JakeStiebs]

I prefer the EDT, for precisely the reason that others opt for the EDP. The EDT is a tad sharper, more in-focus than the EDP...when a perfume is already powdery, I sometimes like the slight edge of an EDT, as the notes stand out in slightly more relief.

Very well said. I love both, but love the EDT more.

 

[dealt7faux]

Edp, because it lasts longer, but I can’t recall the last time I work I wore it.

 

[Ken_Russell]

Another belated vote in favor of this fragrance in its EDP version-also for the most aforementioned reasons, including heightened, improved strength.