rank these creeds from favorite to least favorite

[riffjim4069]

The ones I own: (varies by season)

Green Irish Tweed
Millesime Imperial
Aventus
Tabarome Millesime
Original Santal
Royal Oud
Original Vetiver

 

[iucking_fdiot]

Silver Mountain water
Aventus
Millesime imperial
Git
Himalaya

Sent from my Z1 Compact using Tapatalk

 

[Ken_Russell]

Having few or no less favorite form the ones listed, while my favorites are (in no particular order, since I like all them quite equally much):

GIT, OV, BDP, Tabarome.

 

[3boysmad]

1. Aventus
2. GIT
3. SMW
4. MI

 

[tspencer]

Hmm,

1. Spice & Wood
2. Bois du Portugal
3. Green Irish Tweed (Royal Oud should go here as a tie for 2nd, but you didn't list it)
4. Original Vetiver (Vetiver Geranium should go here, but you didn't list it)
5. Silver Mountain Water (Royal Water should go here but you didn't list it)
6. Green Valley
7. Aventus
8. Tabarome
9. Jardine d'Amalfi
10. Milisime Imperial
11. Virgin Island Water
12. Erolfa
13. Original Santal
14. Himalaya

I would consider adding the following to your list:

Royal Oud
Vetiver Geranium
Royal Water
Royal Mayfair
Viking
Pure White Cologne
Selection Verte
Acier Aluminium

 

[deltasun]

aventus
spice and wood
millesime imperial
virgin island water
bois du portugal
green irish tweed
jardin d'amalfi
silver mountain water - this is now doing some weird acidic thing with my skin
erolfa
himalaya

 

[davidcalgary29]

The best of all:

1. Green Irish Tweed -- I could wear this anytime, anywhere.

Great frag; can't wear it:

2. Jardin d'Amalfi

Great frags, but I have to think if it's suitable for the occasion:

3. Royal Oud
4. Tabarome
5. Aventus

A little flat and unsophisticated, but still nice:

6. Virgin Island Water
7. Viking
8. Himalaya
9. Silver Mountain Water
10. Erolfa
11. Neroli Sauvage

Disliking more with each day:

12. Bois du Portugal
13. Spice and Wood

Scent? What scent?

14. Millesime Imperial

 

[UncleBuck]

Green Valley
Millesime Imperial
Spice and Wood
Green Irish Tweed
Himalaya
Original Vetiver
Virgin Island Water
Silver Mountain Water
Original Santal

 

[tspencer]

A little flat and unsophisticated, but still nice:

7. Viking

I have to say that although I realize it may be an opinion you have, I just don't understand it on this scent. Viking is the most complex Creed fragrance, possibly out of their entire collection. There are so many notes in Viking that when it first came out people were mistakenly comparing it to a multitude of different fragances in different genres even. People were saying Oriental Spicy, Fougere, Woody, Minty, and more. How can that be 'flat'? Viking is the most 'alive' and variable and changing fragrance in the house's offerings. It's not my favorite, but it's definitely not boring.

 

[Diva D]

Original Vetiver
Aventus
Green Irish Tweed
Erolfa
Himalaya
Millesime Imperial
Silver Mountain Water
Original Santal
Virgin Island Water

 

[Bigserver1]

green irish tweed
virgin island water
aventus
millesime imperial
spice and wood
silver mountain water
original vetiver
jardin d’amalfi
erolfa
original santal
himalaya
bois du portugal
tabarome

 

[PrinceRF]

From what I've tried:

Green Irish Tweed
Millesime Imperial
Virgin Island Water
Silver Mountain Water
Original Santal
Himalaya
Aventus
Original Vetiver

 

[davidcalgary29]

I have to say that although I realize it may be an opinion you have, I just don't understand it on this scent. Viking is the most complex Creed fragrance, possibly out of their entire collection. There are so many notes in Viking that when it first came out people were mistakenly comparing it to a multitude of different fragances in different genres even. People were saying Oriental Spicy, Fougere, Woody, Minty, and more. How can that be 'flat'? Viking is the most 'alive' and variable and changing fragrance in the house's offerings. It's not my favorite, but it's definitely not boring.

Well perhaps, but the caveat to this conversation is always the qualification "...on my skin". I occasionally do spray frags on pocket squares, but I can't really buy (and judge) frags on potential, or how they might perform on other people, or on fabric. I've got the best results from Viking, by far, when I'm on vacation in a hot and humid tropical locale: the first time I tried it on vacation, I thought to myself "okay, so THAT'S what it's supposed to smell like!". But I live in a cold, arid place, and it doesn't really do much on my skin here. I love Creed for their complex scents and the way that they subtly change from opening blast through drydown, and I don't get that nearly as much as I do with GIT or Jardin d'Amalfi (which I don't wear well). GIT smells like GIT on me no matter where I am or the time of the year, and that versatility puts it on the top of the list for me.

 

[The_Cologneist]

green irish tweed
green valley
himalaya
virgin island water
silver mountain water
aventus
spice and wood
erolfa
original vetiver

Didn't add the ones I've only tried once, since I don't have enough of a grasp on them fully.

 

[griploc]

I have to say that although I realize it may be an opinion you have, I just don't understand it on this scent. Viking is the most complex Creed fragrance, possibly out of their entire collection. There are so many notes in Viking that when it first came out people were mistakenly comparing it to a multitude of different fragances in different genres even. People were saying Oriental Spicy, Fougere, Woody, Minty, and more. How can that be 'flat'? Viking is the most 'alive' and variable and changing fragrance in the house's offerings. It's not my favorite, but it's definitely not boring.

Viking reminds me of a flatter Old Spice. I really enjoy layering it with Royal Oud, very nice touch

 

[dazbang]

Currently of the ones I have / tried:
green irish tweed (just perfect for any occasion, and usually the one I reach for when I can't decide what to wear)
Royal Water (wasn't on the list but I think this is beautiful)
erolfa
bois du portugal
himalaya
silver mountain water
virgin island water
original vetiver
aventus (I'm really torn on this as I really appreciate the beauty of it, but I smell it (or one of the many clones) everywhere ad nauseum)
millesime imperial
original santal


tabarome (the only one I actively dislike)

 

[StylinLA]

I've tried a lot and owned/sold a few.

For me:

Bois du Portugal
Vetiver 1948
Royal Oud
Virgin Island Water
Original Vetiver
Millesime Imperial
Silver Mountain Water
Pure White Cologne


I've never clicked with Aventus

 

[N.CAL Fragrance Reviewer]

Green Irish Tweed
Virgin Island Water
Millesime Imperial
Bois du Portugal
Green Valley
Original Vetiver
Erolfa
Spice and Wood
Silver Mountain Water
Jardin d'Amalfi
Himalaya
Tabarome Millesime
Original Santal
Aventus

 

[OldSchoolScents]

Viking
Green Irish Tweed
Royal Oud
Bois du Portugal
Aventus
Original Santal

 

[Mythrol]

---- Great ----
Spice & Wood
Aventus
Original Vetiver
Santal Imperial
Vetiver 1948
Millesime Imperial
Virgin Island Water
Silver Mountain Water

---- Good ----
Erolfa
Original Santal
Himalaya
Jardin D'Amalfi

---- I Can Appreciate But Not For Me ----
green irish tweed
green valley
bois du portugal
tabarome