• We're half back! There's a lot missing, but you can find out more here,

    You are now able to log into the forums and post

M is for Montale. Exclusive Interview with Pierre Montale

Vinrambo09

Well-known member
Jan 14, 2010
5,479
112
M is for Montale. Exclusive Interview with Pierre Montale
04/19/16 14:03:51
by: Juliett Ptoyan


Our meeting with Pierre Montale at the Montale & Mancera booth during Esxence happened almost out of the blue; until then, the man behind the two most debated contemporary brands wouldn't allow to be photographed and never gave an interview. But that day he agreed to talk, because, as he said, "Nothing's impossible for Fragrantica".



Three Montale novelties at Esxence 2016: Tropical Wood, Oudmazing and Aoud Lagoon

How did you start your career in perfumery?

My family and I founded Comptoir Sud Pacifique, but after 15 years my sister decided to sell this business, and I headed to Saudi: I worked there, in Qatar, and Dubai with different perfumeries. After 5 years, I came back to Europe and presented Montale, a brand focused on oud fragrances, which put the European public in touch with this oriental ingredient. We started with a boutique at the parisian Place Vendôme, where our first sales began. Mancera was born later, when some of our customers mentioned a discomfort with using aluminum bottles (they wanted to know how much juice was still inside) – but just when we launched Mancera, everyone began to love Montale! (laughing) Anyway, Mancera gathered its customers too – so everyone is happy.

Let's talk a bit about your "eastern" period.

Over there, I worked not only with perfumeries, but also created bespoke fragrances for regals, like for example the Qatar royal family. Also it was a time of blending juices for weddings...

Do the arab people have special requirements for bridal scents?

No, but they love oud in any form. Bridal scents, just like bespoke fragrances, I produced in bottles similar to Montale, but without a logo — instead, they were engraved with the name of the consignee. A bit later, Roses Musk became a best seller in Saudi – it's good for both men and women.




How, and why, did you decide to introduce oud to the European public?


When I worked in Saudi, the main ingredient of all fragrances was oud. Number one – oud, number two – oud... And when I tried it for the first time, I was like, "Oh my God, what is it?!". It was very intens, strong for me. But later, we forged a bond, and I took my wife to try a mix of oud and rose. She immediately loved it – so that's how the first five Montale fragrances I've created had agarwood in the base.

There is a gossip among your fans that Montale is focused on the oriental markets, and Mancera on the European ones. What do you think about that?

No, both brands have success in the European as well as the Arabian market. It's a 50/50 story. Though for the last three years I've created more perfumes for Montale – just because Mancera customers love more fresh fragrances, light, you know.

Ok, what about the story about the fake Montales? This hurt both you and your customers; when did this story begin and how it is now?

The producer of the fake Montales was only one person, a very dangerous man, who had a factory in Dubai. But this story is over, because in 2013 we prevailed and his business was bankrupted. Anyway, the traces of his deals still can be found on the market. The main distinctive characteristic of an original Montale is the address on the box: if you see 68, rue Pierre Charron or 26, place Vendome everything is ok; if there's Dubai address – it's fake. Also, you need to check the cellophane: on the base there should always be a country code.




So, let's get back to the rumors: for the longest time we heard Montale was a shared business, one part located in Paris, and another in Egypt. How can you comment it?

It's interesting, I've never heard it before (laughing). In fact, all the management of company is the same as in the beginning: there's me, the perfumer, and two of my brands, Montale and Mancera. There's only one team for both of them, and we have never shared the company with anyone. But there's nothing strange about such gossip, because there are many designers who work with different brands, and the same counts for noses.

Many of us are interested in your phenomenal productivity...

Oh, this is my dream! In fact, I produce 9 new products each year. This is not our plan, but the market requirement – because, you know, women visit a perfumery boutique, and their first question is: "What's new?". If you have news, customer will come back – this rule works the same in France, Russia or Saudi. If you have novelties, you'll have interest from clients. And not only with clients it works this way, also my distributor calls me: "Hello, Mr. Montale! What's new?" (laughing). So these are just marketing requirements, we cannot ignore them.



Have you launched some exclusive scents for different countries?

Yes, we are already working on something interesting for Russia. I cannot unveil the details, but it will have an equal beauty both inside and out. As for other countries – no, there weren't any exclusives yet, but only because we didn't see a necessity in them. The Arab countries speak highly of us... Russia does too, of course, but Russian clients love limited, exclusive editions. The situation in the east is different.
 

hednic

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2007
388,053
41,113
Had read it earlier on the other site. Interesting. Glad that's cleared up.
 
Last edited:

DerangedGoose

New member
Jan 27, 2009
2,002
6
I suppose its a good thing that we can stop hearing about watered down imitations of the Paris originals, but supposedly the ME Montale line had some homegrown creations that were decent. I only tried one (Aoud & Pine) and found it to be juvenile syrup for little girls, but some of the other ones were alleged to be better...
 

Buysblind

New member
Jan 21, 2011
16,847
48
Glad I read this. I still didn't have the whole Montale/Mancera thing straightened out.
 

Vinrambo09

Well-known member
Jan 14, 2010
5,479
112
Most of the interview is BS though. The Mid East releases were LEGIT, they were being sold in high ends stores in the GCC (Gazzaz , Paris Gallery)
Such high end stores would not risk their reputation to sell counterfeit items lol. What I found shady, is Pierre Montale ie Durrani didn't even take a picture lol.
 

freewheelingvagabond

Well-known member
Jun 10, 2012
27,176
5,367
Most of the interview is BS though. The Mid East releases were LEGIT, they were being sold in high ends stores in the GCC (Gazzaz , Paris Gallery)
Such high end stores would not risk their reputation to sell counterfeit items lol. What I found shady, is Pierre Montale ie Durrani didn't even take a picture lol.

Precisely what I was thinking......
 

gerbick

Well-known member
Jun 13, 2009
3,836
2,175
Not sure I can get behind the "mystery" behind the no photos/no interviews (until now) and of course all of the controversy behind these brands... but I have to say that some of their scents are just great. Oh well...
 

Ovcharkaowner

New member
Jul 2, 2011
6,414
15
Most of the interview is BS though. The Mid East releases were LEGIT, they were being sold in high ends stores in the GCC (Gazzaz , Paris Gallery)
Such high end stores would not risk their reputation to sell counterfeit items lol. What I found shady, is Pierre Montale ie Durrani didn't even take a picture lol.
LOL, i agree. Poor interviewer got scammed by Durrani. Now i know why that other site removed all the Atmeh Montales from their database. Obviously Durrani has friends within the other site's staff.
 

rum

Moderator
Basenotes Plus
Mar 17, 2011
16,224
997
Well that might explain his strategy behind the pathetic attempts at "new" scents each year round. It's a marketing ploy; that's what he's basically saying. Marketing ploy to get people back in to the stores to buy the same old boring and unimaginative oud-rose combo.

Still, it's a worthwhile read and good to hear something (anything!) from a less-spoken CEO of a perfume brand.
 

Vinrambo09

Well-known member
Jan 14, 2010
5,479
112
So Aoud Legacy, Aoud Heritage etc are fakes?

NO, they were Mid East exclusives.The fact they were being sold in high end stores in the region, says other wise, Montale (mid east branch) even had their own kiosk in a upscale Beirut dept store, which sells other niche/luxury brands.
 

TLS

New member
Dec 4, 2012
5,217
10
NO, they were Mid East exclusives.The fact they were being sold in high end stores in the region, says other wise, Montale (mid east branch) even had their own kiosk in a upscale Beirut dept store, which sells other niche/luxury brands.

Thank's.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
267,052
Messages
5,063,912
Members
205,367
Latest member
whiffwizard
Top