• We're half back! There's a lot missing, but you can find out more here,

    You are now able to log into the forums and post

Biggest surprises in Perfumes The Guide 2018?

scentseater

New member
Jun 6, 2016
64
0
With the electronic version of The Guide 2018 released, has anyone had an opportunity to run across any interesting tidbits?
 

the_good_life

Basenotes Plus
Basenotes Plus
Jun 2, 2006
6,449
575
Luca has caught on to the fact that Ellena didn't put much care into his Hermès stuff anymore at some point. I never thought much of the Jardin series to begin with, but Mr. Li is the first one to get a thumbs down here.
 

Redneck Perfumisto

League of Cycloöctadiene Isomer Aestheticists
Basenotes Plus
Feb 27, 2008
26,900
4,087
Luca has caught on to the fact that Ellena didn't put much care into his Hermès stuff anymore at some point. I never thought much of the Jardin series to begin with, but Mr. Li is the first one to get a thumbs down here.

YES. Nil made me wake up, buy it, and go back and collect Méditerranée, and I tolerated the overall oddity of Mousson for its wonderful magic moments. Toit was the first one where I hemmed and hawed, but eventually got it - I think - not kidding - have to check - :rolleyesold: - LOL. But M. Li just lost me. Unnecessary.
 

cacio

Basenotes Plus
Basenotes Plus
Nov 5, 2010
24,064
1,084
I remember he had been very positive on Alaia and negative on Li somewhere before (stylearabia perhaps?)
 

pluran

Well-known member
Mar 2, 2006
10,487
192
That there are even a hell of a lot more things I want to sample than I expected.
 

zachong

New member
Feb 3, 2016
174
2
Parfums di Nicolai New York Intense. 'powdery biscuit' according to Luca Turin is apparently a 5-star masterpiece.



You can thank epapsiou for that. :wink: See Post #14 in old thread.

That sounds promising! I remember him saying about the original that even in the hands of a master perfumer it couldn't be saved from reformulations. Now I've got to hunt it down.
 

Redneck Perfumisto

League of Cycloöctadiene Isomer Aestheticists
Basenotes Plus
Feb 27, 2008
26,900
4,087
That there are even a hell of a lot more things I want to sample than I expected.

YES!

This reminds me how the first guide changed my wardrobe. I tried many new fragrances based on a desire to sample all of the 5-star fragrances, and most of the 4-star scents, as well as the 1-star. I obtained many of them (including 1-star), always noting the truth of what Luca and Tania had written.
 

Kaern

Basenotes Plus
Basenotes Plus
Apr 2, 2008
14,147
88
the 4 stars for Aventus was flagged up some time ago

Monsieur Li is the only one I like from the Jardins -- oh well :embarassed:
 

Dane

New member
Jan 9, 2002
5,461
299
Biggest surprise is that I don't recognize most of the perfume houses - I feel like an old man listening to Top 40.

Sadly, I'm also at the point where I don't care to seek out the unknown.
 
D

Deleted member 26209986

Guest
That there are even a hell of a lot more things I want to sample than I expected.

Same here. I've started a list of perfumes to find while in duty free coming up. Several houses I've never heard of before (living in a rural area for 3 years will do that).
 

Scarce

Well-known member
Dec 28, 2014
4,734
38
Biggest surprise is that I don't recognize most of the perfume houses - I feel like an old man listening to Top 40.

Sadly, I'm also at the point where I don't care to seek out the unknown.

Same here. A lot of houses I've never heard of before, and I thought I was reasonably up on this stuff.

Seeking out the unknown used to be a lot more fun, but the realization that even if you find the latest new great thing, it's likely to be $250 for 50ml, or $10 for not even a 1ml sample. That's enough to give anyone pause.
 

Duke Hunt

New member
Sep 17, 2010
6,148
7
Same here. A lot of houses I've never heard of before, and I thought I was reasonably up on this stuff.

Seeking out the unknown used to be a lot more fun, but the realization that even if you find the latest new great thing, it's likely to be $250 for 50ml, or $10 for not even a 1ml sample. That's enough to give anyone pause.

Yes and to add insult to injury, by the time you do finally pull the trigger it’s either been reformulated 10 times or suffering from “batch variation”.
 

Dane

New member
Jan 9, 2002
5,461
299
Same here. A lot of houses I've never heard of before, and I thought I was reasonably up on this stuff.

Seeking out the unknown used to be a lot more fun, but the realization that even if you find the latest new great thing, it's likely to be $250 for 50ml, or $10 for not even a 1ml sample. That's enough to give anyone pause.

Seriously - and the one sample I thought I would seek out sent me a message saying they won't ship to Canada. Sigh.
 

Kaern

Basenotes Plus
Basenotes Plus
Apr 2, 2008
14,147
88
It's what I said in another thread -- 'Niche' is becoming a con for most people

Designer fragrances are a con to but it's costing us less to learn the lesson
 

Forum statistics

Threads
267,201
Messages
5,069,079
Members
205,500
Latest member
Gail Code
Top